Back to blog

UTM Tagging vs Traditional Tracking Techniques: An Overview

November 17, 2023 | Jimit Mehta

In the world of digital marketing, tracking and measuring the success of campaigns is crucial for businesses to make informed decisions. There are a variety of techniques available for tracking the performance of campaigns, but two of the most popular are UTM tagging and traditional tracking methods. Both of these techniques have their own advantages and disadvantages, and choosing the right one for your business can be a challenge. In this article, we'll take a closer look at UTM tagging vs traditional tracking techniques and provide an overview of what each method involves, so you can decide which approach is best for your business.

Definition of UTM Tagging

UTM tagging is a simple yet effective method of tracking the performance of online campaigns. It involves adding specific tracking parameters, known as UTM tags, to the end of a URL. These tags allow marketers to track the success of their campaigns by providing information on where clicks are coming from and how users are interacting with their website. By using UTM tags, marketers can get a more detailed understanding of the effectiveness of their campaigns and make data-driven decisions to improve their marketing strategies.

In essence, UTM tagging is a way of labeling URLs in order to accurately track and measure the success of online marketing efforts.

Personalize every website interaction
Try for free

Definition of Traditional Tracking Techniques

Traditional tracking techniques refer to the methods that have been used for many years to track the performance of marketing campaigns. These techniques include using basic web analytics tools, such as Google Analytics, to track website traffic and monitor the number of visitors to a site.

Additionally, traditional tracking techniques may involve using cookies to track user behavior on a website and to understand which pages are performing well and which ones need improvement. Another common traditional tracking technique is using phone call tracking, where unique phone numbers are assigned to different marketing campaigns in order to track the source of calls and measure the success of campaigns. In essence, traditional tracking techniques rely on basic web analytics tools and cookie tracking to monitor and measure the success of campaigns.

Comparison of UTM Tagging and Traditional Tracking Techniques

UTM tagging and traditional tracking techniques both have their own unique strengths and weaknesses, and the choice between them will depend on the specific needs and goals of your business.

One of the biggest advantages of UTM tagging is that it provides more granular and detailed information about the performance of campaigns. With UTM tags, you can track not only the number of clicks on a link, but also where the clicks are coming from, what keywords are driving traffic, and even which specific ad or email a user clicked on. This level of detail allows you to make data-driven decisions to improve your campaigns and increase their effectiveness.

Traditional tracking techniques, on the other hand, are often easier to set up and less complex to use. For example, with basic web analytics tools, you can quickly see the number of visitors to your site and the pages they visited, without having to set up any additional tracking parameters. Additionally, traditional tracking techniques are often less intrusive for users, as they typically rely on cookies that are stored on a user's device, rather than adding tracking parameters to the end of a URL.

Ultimately, the choice between UTM tagging and traditional tracking techniques will depend on the specific goals and needs of your business. UTM tagging may be the best choice if you're looking for detailed and granular information about the performance of your campaigns, while traditional tracking techniques may be a better choice if you're looking for a simpler and more straightforward approach to tracking your campaigns.

Advantages of UTM Tagging

UTM tagging is a powerful tool for tracking the performance of online campaigns, and it comes with several advantages over traditional tracking techniques. Some of the key benefits of UTM tagging include:

  1. Granular and Detailed Tracking: UTM tags provide a wealth of information about the performance of campaigns, including where clicks are coming from, what keywords are driving traffic, and even which specific ad or email a user clicked on. This level of detail allows you to make data-driven decisions to improve your campaigns and increase their effectiveness.

  2. Easy to Set Up: UTM tags can be easily added to the end of a URL using simple tools and techniques, making it quick and easy to get started with tracking your campaigns.

  3. Works Across Multiple Platforms: UTM tags work across all platforms, including social media, email, and other marketing channels, providing a unified view of your campaign performance.

  4. Integration with Analytics Tools: UTM tags can be easily integrated with web analytics tools such as Google Analytics, allowing you to see the impact of your campaigns in real-time and make informed decisions to improve your marketing strategies.

  5. Measurable Results: With UTM tags, you can accurately measure the success of your campaigns and track your return on investment, making it easier to determine which campaigns are working and which ones need improvement.

In conclusion, UTM tagging is a valuable tool for tracking the performance of online campaigns, and its granular and detailed tracking, ease of use, and integration with analytics tools make it a powerful tool for businesses looking to improve their marketing strategies.

Advantages of Traditional Tracking Techniques

Traditional tracking techniques have been used for many years to track the performance of marketing campaigns, and they continue to be popular due to their simplicity and ease of use. Some of the key advantages of traditional tracking techniques include:

  1. Simplicity: Traditional tracking techniques, such as basic web analytics tools, are easy to set up and use, making it simple to get started with tracking your campaigns.

  2. Wide Availability: Basic web analytics tools, such as Google Analytics, are widely available and free to use, making them accessible to businesses of all sizes.

  3. User-Friendly: Traditional tracking techniques, such as cookie tracking, are typically less intrusive for users, as they rely on cookies stored on a user's device, rather than adding tracking parameters to the end of a URL.

  4. Integration with Other Tools: Traditional tracking techniques, such as phone call tracking, can be easily integrated with other marketing tools, such as CRM systems, to provide a comprehensive view of your campaign performance.

  5. Quick Results: With traditional tracking techniques, you can quickly see the results of your campaigns and make informed decisions to improve your marketing strategies.

In conclusion, traditional tracking techniques provide a simple and straightforward approach to tracking the performance of marketing campaigns. Their simplicity, wide availability, user-friendliness, and integration with other tools make them a popular choice for businesses of all sizes.

Limitations of UTM Tagging

UTM tagging is a powerful tool for tracking the performance of online campaigns, but like all tools, it has its own limitations. Some of the key limitations of UTM tagging include:

  1. Complexity: While UTM tags can provide a wealth of information about the performance of campaigns, they can also be complex to set up and use, especially for businesses that are new to tracking their campaigns.

  2. User Intrusion: Adding UTM tags to the end of a URL can be intrusive for users, as it can make the URL longer and less user-friendly. This can result in a lower click-through rate and reduced engagement with your campaigns.

  3. Data Accuracy: The accuracy of the data collected using UTM tags can be impacted by factors such as incorrect tagging, incorrect setup of analytics tools, and tracking parameters being stripped from URLs. This can result in inaccurate data and a reduced understanding of the performance of your campaigns.

  4. Limited Integration: While UTM tags can be integrated with web analytics tools, they may not be integrated with other marketing tools, such as CRM systems, resulting in a fragmented view of your campaign performance.

In conclusion, while UTM tagging is a valuable tool for tracking the performance of online campaigns, its complexity, user intrusion, limited data accuracy, and limited integration with other tools can make it challenging to use effectively. Businesses should carefully consider these limitations when deciding whether UTM tagging is the right approach for their needs.

Limitations of Traditional Tracking Techniques

Traditional tracking techniques, such as basic web analytics tools and cookie tracking, have been widely used for many years to track the performance of marketing campaigns, but they also have their own limitations. Some of the key limitations of traditional tracking techniques include:

  1. Limited Detail: Traditional tracking techniques typically provide a limited view of campaign performance, with basic web analytics tools only providing basic information such as the number of visitors to a site and the pages they visited. This can make it difficult to make data-driven decisions to improve your campaigns.

  2. Inaccurate Data: The accuracy of the data collected using traditional tracking techniques can be impacted by factors such as users blocking cookies, incorrect setup of analytics tools, and inaccurate tracking of phone calls. This can result in inaccurate data and a reduced understanding of the performance of your campaigns.

  3. Lack of Integration: Traditional tracking techniques, such as phone call tracking, may not be integrated with other marketing tools, such as CRM systems, resulting in a fragmented view of your campaign performance.

  4. Limited Customization: Traditional tracking techniques may not provide the level of customization that businesses require to track their campaigns effectively, making it difficult to track specific metrics and KPIs.

In conclusion, while traditional tracking techniques provide a simple and straightforward approach to tracking the performance of marketing campaigns, their limited detail, inaccurate data, lack of integration, and limited customization can make it challenging to use them effectively. Businesses should carefully consider these limitations when deciding whether traditional tracking techniques are the right approach for their needs.

UTM Tagging in Action

UTM tagging is a simple yet effective technique for tracking the performance of online campaigns, and it works by adding specific tracking parameters, known as UTM tags, to the end of a URL. These tags allow marketers to track the success of their campaigns by providing information on where clicks are coming from and how users are interacting with their website.

Here's how UTM tagging works in action:

  1. Creating UTM Tags: The first step in using UTM tags is to create them. This can be done using a UTM builder tool, which generates the tags based on the information you provide, such as the source, medium, campaign name, and other tracking parameters.

  2. Adding UTM Tags to URLs: Once the UTM tags have been created, they can be added to the end of the URLs for your campaigns. This can be done manually, or using a link management tool that automatically adds the tags to your URLs.

  3. Tracking Campaign Performance: With UTM tags in place, the performance of your campaigns can be tracked using web analytics tools, such as Google Analytics. The tags provide information on where clicks are coming from, what keywords are driving traffic, and even which specific ad or email a user clicked on.

  4. Making Data-Driven Decisions: With the data collected using UTM tags, marketers can make data-driven decisions to improve their campaigns and increase their effectiveness. For example, they may see that a particular ad is not performing well, and choose to optimize it or replace it with a different ad.

In conclusion, UTM tagging is a valuable tool for tracking the performance of online campaigns, and its simplicity and effectiveness make it a popular choice for businesses looking to improve their marketing strategies. By adding UTM tags to URLs, tracking campaign performance using web analytics tools, and making data-driven decisions based on the data collected, businesses can gain a deeper understanding of the performance of their campaigns and make informed decisions to improve their marketing strategies.

Traditional Tracking Techniques in Action

Traditional tracking techniques refer to the methods that have been used for many years to track the performance of marketing campaigns, including basic web analytics tools and cookie tracking. These techniques provide a simple and straightforward approach to tracking the performance of campaigns, making them a popular choice for businesses of all sizes.

Here's how traditional tracking techniques work in action:

  1. Setting up Web Analytics: The first step in using traditional tracking techniques is to set up basic web analytics tools, such as Google Analytics, on your website. This involves adding a tracking code to your website, which will allow you to track the number of visitors to your site and the pages they visited.

  2. Tracking User Behavior with Cookies: Another traditional tracking technique is using cookies to track user behavior on your website. Cookies are small text files stored on a user's device, which track their behavior on your website, such as which pages they visited and how long they spent on each page.

  3. Phone Call Tracking: Another traditional tracking technique is using phone call tracking, where unique phone numbers are assigned to different marketing campaigns in order to track the source of calls and measure the success of campaigns.

  4. Quick Results: With traditional tracking techniques, such as basic web analytics tools and cookie tracking, you can quickly see the results of your campaigns and make informed decisions to improve your marketing strategies.

In conclusion, traditional tracking techniques provide a simple and straightforward approach to tracking the performance of marketing campaigns. Their simplicity, wide availability, user-friendliness, and quick results make them a popular choice for businesses of all sizes. By using basic web analytics tools, cookie tracking, and phone call tracking, businesses can gain a basic understanding of the performance of their campaigns and make informed decisions to improve their marketing strategies.

Choosing the Right Tracking Method for Your Business

Choosing the right tracking method for your business is crucial for measuring the success of your campaigns and making informed decisions to improve your marketing strategies. There are two main options for tracking the performance of campaigns: UTM tagging and traditional tracking techniques. Both methods have their own unique strengths and weaknesses, and the choice between them will depend on the specific needs and goals of your business.

When choosing the right tracking method for your business, consider the following:

  1. Campaign Goals: What are the specific goals of your campaigns? Do you want to track the success of specific ads or emails, or simply track the overall performance of your campaigns? UTM tagging provides more granular and detailed information about the performance of campaigns, making it a good choice if you want to track specific aspects of your campaigns.

  2. Data Accuracy: How important is data accuracy to your business? UTM tags can provide a wealth of information about the performance of campaigns, but the accuracy of the data collected can be impacted by factors such as incorrect tagging and incorrect setup of analytics tools. If data accuracy is a priority, consider using UTM tagging.

  3. Ease of Use: How easy is it to set up and use the tracking method you're considering? UTM tagging can be complex to set up and use, especially for businesses that are new to tracking their campaigns. If ease of use is a priority, consider using traditional tracking techniques, such as basic web analytics tools.

  4. User Intrusion: Does the tracking method you're considering add tracking parameters to the end of URLs, or rely on cookies stored on a user's device? UTM tags can be intrusive for users, as they can make URLs longer and less user-friendly. If user intrusion is a concern, consider using traditional tracking techniques, such as cookie tracking.

In conclusion, choosing the right tracking method for your business depends on your specific goals and needs. Consider the goals of your campaigns, data accuracy, ease of use, and user intrusion when deciding which method is right for your business. By choosing the right tracking method, you can measure the success of your campaigns and make informed decisions to improve your marketing strategies.

Wrapping up

UTM tagging and traditional tracking techniques are two methods for tracking the performance of online campaigns. UTM tagging provides more granular and detailed information about the performance of campaigns, allowing businesses to make data-driven decisions to improve their campaigns. However, UTM tagging can be complex to set up and use, and can also be intrusive for users. Traditional tracking techniques, such as basic web analytics tools and cookie tracking, are simple to set up and use, and are less intrusive for users.

However, traditional tracking techniques typically provide a limited view of campaign performance and may not be as accurate as UTM tagging. When choosing the right tracking method for your business, consider your specific goals, data accuracy, ease of use, and user intrusion. By choosing the right method, you can measure the success of your campaigns and make informed decisions to improve your marketing strategies.

Want to use UTM tags to personalize your website for different campaigns? Try Markettailor for free.


Related posts

UTM Tagging vs Traditional Tracking Methods: A Side-by-Side Comparison

Tracking your website's performance and marketing efforts can be a crucial aspect of running a successful business. With the multitude of tools and methods available, it can be overwhelming to determine which one is best for your needs. Two popular methods for tracking website data are UTM tagging...

Read more

UTM Tagging vs Other Tracking Methods: An In-Depth Comparison

As marketers, we are always on the lookout for ways to measure the success of our campaigns and make data-driven decisions. One of the most important tools in our arsenal is tracking and measurement. Whether you're running a paid advertising campaign, a social media campaign, or just want to track...

Read more