Back to blog

5 common mistakes businesses make when segmenting customers

November 18, 2023 | Jimit Mehta

If you've ever worked in or run a business, you know that customers are the lifeblood of any successful enterprise. But with so many customers out there, it can be difficult to figure out how to reach and connect with each one. That's where customer segmentation comes in - it's the process of dividing customers into groups based on shared characteristics so that you can create targeted marketing strategies for each segment.

Sounds simple, right? Well, not quite. As it turns out, there are some common mistakes that businesses make when segmenting their customers. These mistakes can lead to wasted time and resources, missed opportunities, and even alienating some of your best customers. In this article, we'll explore five of the most common mistakes that businesses make when segmenting their customers and what you can do to avoid them. So whether you're a seasoned business owner or just starting out, keep reading to learn how to get the most out of your customer segmentation efforts.

Overlooking important customer characteristics

When businesses segment their customers, they often start by looking at basic demographics like age, gender, and location. While these characteristics can be helpful in creating broad customer segments, they can also lead to overlooking other important characteristics that can be key to understanding customer behavior and preferences.

For example, a company that sells pet supplies might assume that all dog owners are essentially the same, but in reality, there are many factors that can differentiate one dog owner from another. Some dog owners may prioritize organic, natural dog food, while others may prefer bargain-priced products. By overlooking these important characteristics, the business may fail to create effective marketing strategies for each customer segment.

To avoid this mistake, businesses should take the time to analyze and understand the full range of customer characteristics that are relevant to their industry and product offerings. This can include factors like shopping habits, product preferences, brand loyalty, and more. By taking a more holistic approach to customer segmentation, businesses can gain a deeper understanding of their customers and create more effective strategies for each segment.

Personalize every website interaction
Try for free

Failing to adjust segments over time

Businesses that segment their customers often fall into the trap of assuming that the segments they create will remain static over time. However, customer needs and behaviors are constantly evolving, and failing to adjust customer segments can lead to missed opportunities and ineffective marketing strategies.

For example, a business that sells workout equipment may have created a customer segment for fitness enthusiasts who prefer home workouts. However, if this business fails to adjust its segments over time, it may miss out on a growing segment of customers who are interested in high-intensity workouts or yoga. By continuing to target only the original segment, the business may miss out on potential sales and fail to connect with its evolving customer base.

To avoid this mistake, businesses should regularly review and update their customer segments based on new data and insights. This can include tracking changes in customer behaviors and preferences, as well as keeping an eye on broader industry trends. By being proactive in adjusting customer segments, businesses can stay ahead of the curve and create more effective marketing strategies that resonate with their evolving customer base.

Creating too many or too few segments

One of the key challenges of customer segmentation is striking the right balance between creating too many or too few segments. If a business creates too many segments, it can become difficult to create targeted marketing strategies for each one. On the other hand, if a business creates too few segments, it may miss out on key nuances in customer behavior and preferences.

For example, a business that sells outdoor clothing and gear might create a customer segment for hikers and another for backpackers. However, if the business creates too many sub-segments, such as "day hikers" and "thru-hikers" and "weekend backpackers" and "long-distance backpackers," it may struggle to create targeted marketing strategies for each one. On the other hand, if the business only creates a single segment for all outdoor enthusiasts, it may miss out on important differences in gear and apparel preferences.

To strike the right balance, businesses should consider both the breadth and depth of their customer segments. It's important to have enough segments to capture key differences in customer behavior and preferences, but not so many that it becomes unwieldy to create effective marketing strategies for each one. By finding the right balance, businesses can create targeted marketing strategies that connect with each segment while still being efficient and effective.

Neglecting to personalize messaging and offers to each segment

Personalization has become increasingly important in marketing, and for good reason. Customers are more likely to engage with and respond to marketing messages that feel personalized and relevant to their needs and preferences. However, businesses that segment their customers can fall into the trap of neglecting to personalize messaging and offers to each segment.

For example, a business that sells home goods might create a customer segment for new homeowners. However, if the business fails to personalize its messaging and offers to this segment, it may struggle to connect with customers who are looking for specific products to outfit their new homes. Instead, the business may send generic marketing messages that don't resonate with the segment, or it may send offers for products that the customer has already purchased.

To avoid this mistake, businesses should create targeted messaging and offers for each customer segment. This can include customized emails, personalized product recommendations, and targeted promotions that are tailored to each segment's unique needs and preferences. By personalizing messaging and offers, businesses can build stronger relationships with customers and increase the likelihood of making a sale.

Relying solely on demographic data to segment customers

When it comes to customer segmentation, many businesses rely solely on demographic data like age, gender, and income. While this data can be useful in creating broad customer segments, it's important to recognize that demographic data alone is not enough to fully understand customer needs and preferences.

For example, a business that sells athletic shoes might assume that all young, active customers are essentially the same, but in reality, there may be a wide range of differences in preferences and behaviors within this demographic. Some customers may prioritize durability and support, while others may prefer lightweight and stylish shoes. By relying solely on demographic data, the business may miss out on key nuances in customer behavior and preferences.

To avoid this mistake, businesses should use a more comprehensive approach to customer segmentation that takes into account a range of data points beyond demographics. This can include data on customer shopping habits, product preferences, brand loyalty, and more. By taking a more holistic approach to customer segmentation, businesses can gain a deeper understanding of their customers and create more effective marketing strategies that are tailored to each segment's unique needs and preferences.

Over to you

Customer segmentation is an important strategy that helps businesses understand and connect with different groups of customers. However, there are several common mistakes that businesses make when segmenting customers.

The first mistake is overlooking important customer characteristics. Businesses that fail to consider key nuances in customer behavior and preferences may struggle to create effective marketing strategies.

The second mistake is failing to adjust customer segments over time. Customer needs and behaviors are constantly evolving, and businesses that fail to adapt their segments can miss out on potential sales and fail to connect with their customer base.

The third mistake is creating too many or too few segments. Finding the right balance is key to creating effective marketing strategies for each segment while remaining efficient and effective.

The fourth mistake is neglecting to personalize messaging and offers to each segment. Personalization is increasingly important in marketing, and businesses that fail to create targeted messaging and offers for each segment may struggle to build strong relationships with customers.

Finally, businesses that rely solely on demographic data to segment customers may miss out on key nuances in customer behavior and preferences. To create effective customer segments, businesses should take a more holistic approach that considers a range of data points beyond demographics.

By avoiding these common mistakes, businesses can create effective customer segments that help them connect with and serve their customers more effectively.

Want show different customer segments more relevant content using personalization? Try Markettailor for free.


Related posts

The role of customer segmentation in creating targeted content marketing campaigns

In the world of marketing, one size doesn't fit all. Gone are the days of generic ads and bland messaging that appeals to no one in particular. As competition gets stiffer and customer preferences continue to evolve, businesses are forced to up their game to stand out from the crowd. This is where...

Read more

The benefits of segmenting customers for email marketing

Email marketing is a crucial aspect of any business. It is a cost-effective way to reach out to potential and existing customers and keep them engaged with your brand. But with so many emails flooding people's inboxes every day, it's important to make sure your message stands out. That's where...

Read more