Back to blog

UTM Tagging vs Traditional Tracking Methods: Pros and Cons

November 17, 2023 | Jimit Mehta

As technology advances and the digital world becomes more complex, it's crucial for businesses to keep up with the latest marketing tactics and tools. One of the most essential components of any digital marketing strategy is tracking and measuring the success of your campaigns. This is where UTM tagging and traditional tracking methods come into play.

UTM tagging is a relatively new technique that has gained popularity in recent years, but it's important to understand both UTM tagging and traditional tracking methods to determine which one is best for your business. In this article, we'll dive into the pros and cons of each method, so you can make an informed decision and choose the best tracking method for your needs. Whether you're a seasoned marketer or just starting out, this article will provide valuable insights that can help you make the most of your digital marketing efforts.

Introduction to UTM Tagging and Traditional Tracking Methods

In this section, we'll provide a basic overview of UTM tagging and traditional tracking methods. This will serve as a foundation for the rest of the article, where we'll dive into each method in more detail.

UTM tagging is a method of tracking website traffic from specific sources, such as email campaigns, social media, or paid ads. It involves adding specific parameters, called UTM parameters, to the end of a URL. These parameters can then be tracked in analytics tools, such as Google Analytics, to see where traffic is coming from and how it's interacting with your website.

Traditional tracking methods, on the other hand, typically involve using tracking codes, such as Google Analytics tracking code, placed on your website to track overall traffic and behavior. While this method provides a general overview of website traffic, it doesn't offer the same level of detail and specificity as UTM tagging.

In this article, we'll take a closer look at both UTM tagging and traditional tracking methods, exploring the pros and cons of each and helping you determine which method is right for your business.

Personalize every website interaction
Try for free

Understanding UTM Tagging

In this section, we'll dive deeper into UTM tagging and what it entails.

UTM tagging is a method of tracking website traffic from specific sources by adding specific parameters, known as UTM parameters, to the end of a URL. These parameters can be tracked in analytics tools, such as Google Analytics, to see where traffic is coming from and how it's interacting with your website.

The five main UTM parameters are:

  1. Source: The source of the traffic, such as "facebook" or "email".
  2. Medium: The medium through which the traffic was generated, such as "social" or "email".
  3. Campaign: The name of the specific campaign, such as "spring_sale".
  4. Term: Used for paid search campaigns to identify the keywords used.
  5. Content: Used to differentiate different ads or links within the same campaign.

By using UTM tags, you can get a much more detailed view of your website traffic and see exactly where it's coming from and how it's interacting with your website. This information can then be used to optimize your marketing efforts and improve the overall performance of your campaigns.

In the next section, we'll take a closer look at the advantages of UTM tagging.

Advantages of UTM Tagging

In this section, we'll discuss the benefits of using UTM tagging as a tracking method.

  1. Increased Visibility: UTM tagging provides a more detailed view of where your website traffic is coming from, making it easier to see which campaigns are driving the most traffic and conversions.

  2. Improved Campaign Tracking: With UTM tagging, you can track specific campaigns and see how they're performing, rather than just tracking overall website traffic. This allows you to make informed decisions about your marketing strategy and improve the performance of your campaigns.

  3. Better Attribution: UTM tags allow you to attribute conversions and sales to specific campaigns, making it easier to see which campaigns are driving the most revenue for your business.

  4. Easy to Implement: UTM tagging is relatively easy to implement and doesn't require any technical expertise. Simply add the UTM parameters to the end of your URL and you're ready to go.

  5. Cost-Effective: UTM tagging is a cost-effective way to track website traffic and performance, making it a great option for businesses of all sizes.

In summary, UTM tagging offers a number of advantages, including increased visibility, improved campaign tracking, better attribution, ease of implementation, and cost-effectiveness. These benefits make UTM tagging a popular choice for businesses looking to track their website traffic and performance.

Limitations of UTM Tagging

In this section, we'll discuss the limitations of using UTM tagging as a tracking method.

  1. Limited to Online Tracking: UTM tagging is only able to track website traffic and performance, so it's not a comprehensive solution for tracking all of your marketing efforts.

  2. Potential for Inconsistent Data: UTM tagging relies on manual implementation, which means there is a risk of human error and inconsistencies in the data.

  3. Limited Ability to Track Offline Conversions: UTM tagging is not able to track offline conversions, such as phone calls or in-person sales, which can limit its usefulness for businesses with a significant offline presence.

  4. URL Length: UTM tags can make URLs longer and less attractive, which can impact the click-through rate of your campaigns.

  5. Requires Regular Maintenance: UTM tagging requires regular maintenance and updates to ensure that the data being tracked is accurate and up-to-date.

In conclusion, while UTM tagging offers a number of advantages, it also has some limitations that should be considered. These limitations include its limited tracking capabilities, potential for inconsistent data, limited ability to track offline conversions, impact on URL length, and need for regular maintenance. These limitations should be taken into consideration when deciding whether UTM tagging is the right choice for your business.

Understanding Traditional Tracking Methods

In this section, we'll discuss traditional tracking methods, which have been used for many years to track website traffic and performance.

Traditional tracking methods typically involve using tracking codes, such as Google Analytics tracking code, placed on your website to track overall traffic and behavior. This method provides a general overview of website traffic, including the number of visitors, the pages they visit, and how long they stay on your site.

With traditional tracking methods, you can see overall trends in your website traffic and performance, but you don't get the same level of detail and specificity as you would with UTM tagging. For example, you won't be able to see which specific campaigns are driving the most traffic or conversions.

While traditional tracking methods may not provide as much detail as UTM tagging, they are still a valuable tool for businesses looking to track their website traffic and performance. They are also easier to set up and maintain, as you simply need to add the tracking code to your website and let it run.

In the next section, we'll take a closer look at the advantages of traditional tracking methods.

Advantages of Traditional Tracking Methods

In this section, we'll discuss the benefits of using traditional tracking methods.

  1. Easy to Implement: Traditional tracking methods, such as Google Analytics, are easy to set up and don't require any technical expertise. Simply add the tracking code to your website and you're ready to go.

  2. No Maintenance Required: Once you've set up your tracking code, you don't need to do anything else. The tracking code will run in the background, providing you with data on your website traffic and performance.

  3. Affordable: Traditional tracking methods are typically free or low-cost, making them a great option for businesses of all sizes.

  4. Comprehensive View of Website Traffic: Traditional tracking methods provide a comprehensive view of your website traffic, including the number of visitors, the pages they visit, and how long they stay on your site.

  5. No Human Error: Traditional tracking methods are automated, so there is no risk of human error or inconsistencies in the data.

In summary, traditional tracking methods offer a number of advantages, including ease of implementation, no maintenance required, affordability, a comprehensive view of website traffic, and no risk of human error. These benefits make traditional tracking methods a popular choice for businesses looking to track their website traffic and performance.

Limitations of Traditional Tracking Methods

In this section, we'll discuss the limitations of using traditional tracking methods.

  1. Limited Detail: Traditional tracking methods provide a general overview of website traffic, but they don't offer the same level of detail and specificity as UTM tagging. For example, you won't be able to see which specific campaigns are driving the most traffic or conversions.

  2. No Attribution: Traditional tracking methods do not allow you to attribute conversions and sales to specific campaigns, which can make it difficult to see which campaigns are driving the most revenue for your business.

  3. Limited Ability to Track Offline Conversions: Traditional tracking methods are not able to track offline conversions, such as phone calls or in-person sales, which can limit their usefulness for businesses with a significant offline presence.

  4. Can't Track Specific Sources: Traditional tracking methods don't allow you to track specific sources of traffic, such as social media or email campaigns, which can make it difficult to see the impact of these campaigns on your website traffic and performance.

  5. Can Be Less Accurate: Traditional tracking methods may not be as accurate as UTM tagging, as they rely on cookies and other technologies that can be blocked or deleted by users.

In conclusion, while traditional tracking methods offer a number of advantages, they also have some limitations that should be considered. These limitations include limited detail, no attribution, limited ability to track offline conversions, inability to track specific sources, and potential for less accuracy. These limitations should be taken into consideration when deciding whether traditional tracking methods are the right choice for your business.

Comparison of UTM Tagging and Traditional Tracking Methods

In this section, we'll compare UTM tagging and traditional tracking methods to help you determine which method is right for your business.

UTM tagging provides a more detailed view of website traffic, allowing you to see exactly where it's coming from and how it's interacting with your website. This level of detail and specificity makes UTM tagging a great choice for businesses looking to track specific campaigns and see the impact of their marketing efforts.

Traditional tracking methods, on the other hand, provide a general overview of website traffic and performance, but they don't offer the same level of detail as UTM tagging. While traditional tracking methods are easy to set up and don't require any maintenance, they may not be as useful for businesses looking to track specific campaigns and see the impact of their marketing efforts.

When deciding between UTM tagging and traditional tracking methods, it's important to consider your specific needs and the type of data you're looking to track. If you're looking for a detailed view of website traffic and the impact of specific campaigns, UTM tagging may be the better choice. However, if you're looking for a comprehensive view of overall website traffic and performance, traditional tracking methods may be the way to go.

In conclusion, UTM tagging and traditional tracking methods each have their own pros and cons, and the best choice for your business will depend on your specific needs and the type of data you're looking to track.

Deciding which method is best for your business

In this section, we'll discuss how to determine which tracking method is best for your business.

When deciding between UTM tagging and traditional tracking methods, there are several factors to consider:

  1. The type of data you're looking to track: If you're looking for a detailed view of website traffic and the impact of specific campaigns, UTM tagging may be the better choice. However, if you're looking for a comprehensive view of overall website traffic and performance, traditional tracking methods may be the way to go.

  2. The size and complexity of your business: UTM tagging may be a better choice for larger, more complex businesses with multiple campaigns and a need for detailed tracking. Smaller businesses may find traditional tracking methods to be more suitable.

  3. Your budget: UTM tagging and traditional tracking methods both have their own costs, and it's important to consider your budget when deciding which method is best for your business.

  4. Your technical expertise: UTM tagging requires a certain level of technical expertise to set up and maintain, so it may not be the best choice for businesses with limited technical resources.

  5. Your marketing goals: Ultimately, the best tracking method for your business will depend on your marketing goals and the type of data you're looking to track.

In conclusion, deciding which tracking method is best for your business will depend on a number of factors, including the type of data you're looking to track, the size and complexity of your business, your budget, your technical expertise, and your marketing goals. It's important to take these factors into consideration when making your decision to ensure you choose the best tracking method for your needs.

Conclusion and Final Thoughts

In conclusion, UTM tagging and traditional tracking methods are both valuable tools for businesses looking to track their website traffic and performance. Each method has its own advantages and limitations, and the best choice for your business will depend on your specific needs and the type of data you're looking to track.

UTM tagging provides a more detailed view of website traffic, making it a great choice for businesses looking to track specific campaigns and see the impact of their marketing efforts. Traditional tracking methods, on the other hand, provide a general overview of website traffic and performance, making them a better choice for businesses looking for a comprehensive view of overall website traffic.

When deciding between UTM tagging and traditional tracking methods, it's important to consider the type of data you're looking to track, the size and complexity of your business, your budget, your technical expertise, and your marketing goals.

In final thoughts, tracking your website traffic and performance is an essential component of any digital marketing strategy. Whether you choose UTM tagging or traditional tracking methods, make sure you choose the right tracking method for your business to ensure you get the most out of your digital marketing efforts.

Wrapping up

In this article, we compared UTM tagging and traditional tracking methods, exploring the pros and cons of each method. UTM tagging provides a more detailed view of website traffic and allows businesses to track specific campaigns, while traditional tracking methods provide a general overview of overall website traffic and performance. When deciding between UTM tagging and traditional tracking methods, it's important to consider the type of data you're looking to track, the size and complexity of your business, your budget, your technical expertise, and your marketing goals.

Both UTM tagging and traditional tracking methods have their own advantages and limitations, and the best choice for your business will depend on your specific needs and goals. Regardless of which method you choose, tracking your website traffic and performance is essential for a successful digital marketing strategy.

Want to use UTM tags to personalize your website for different campaigns? Try Markettailor for free.


Related posts

UTM Tagging vs Other Tracking Methods: A Comparative Study

Tracking the success of your digital marketing campaigns can be a complex and confusing task. With so many different methods to choose from, it can be hard to know which one is right for you. Two of the most popular tracking methods are UTM tagging and other tracking methods. In this article, we...

Read more

UTM Tagging vs Traditional Tracking Methods: Which is Better?

As the digital world continues to evolve, so do the methods we use to track and analyze our online marketing efforts. Two popular tracking methods that have been debated for years are UTM tagging and traditional tracking. But which one is the better option? In this article, we will take a closer...

Read more