Back to blog

How to write compelling subject lines for your emails

November 17, 2023 | Jimit Mehta

Picture this: You've spent hours crafting the perfect email that you just know will knock the socks off of your subscribers. It's informative, it's entertaining, and it's got a great call-to-action that you're sure they won't be able to resist. But there's just one problem: your subject line falls flat. Maybe it's too generic, maybe it's too salesy, or maybe it just doesn't grab your reader's attention. Whatever the reason, your hard work might as well be for nothing if your email never gets opened. So, what's the solution? The answer is simple: you need to write compelling subject lines that will make your readers sit up and take notice. In this article, we'll take a deep dive into the art of subject line writing and give you all the tips and tricks you need to make sure your emails get the attention they deserve.

Understanding the importance of subject lines

Subject lines are often the first thing that a person sees when they receive an email from you. In fact, it's usually the only thing they see before deciding whether or not to open it. That means the subject line is arguably the most important part of your email, as it can make or break your chances of getting someone to engage with your content.

A compelling subject line can pique your reader's interest and encourage them to open your email. On the other hand, a weak or irrelevant subject line may cause your email to be ignored, or worse, sent straight to the spam folder.

It's important to understand the significance of subject lines because they play a critical role in determining the success of your email marketing campaigns. A well-crafted subject line can increase open rates, click-through rates, and ultimately, conversion rates. By contrast, a poorly written subject line can damage your email reputation and hurt your ability to connect with your audience.

To sum it up, understanding the importance of subject lines is crucial for anyone who wants to improve the effectiveness of their email campaigns. By focusing on crafting compelling subject lines, you can increase the chances of your emails being opened and read, and ultimately, achieve your marketing goals.

Personalize every website interaction
Try for free

Tips for crafting attention-grabbing subject lines

Crafting attention-grabbing subject lines is all about getting creative and making a strong impression on your audience. Here are some tips to help you create subject lines that stand out:

  1. Keep it short and sweet: A shorter subject line is easier to read and more likely to grab your reader's attention. Try to keep your subject line to 50 characters or less.

  2. Be clear and specific: Your subject line should accurately reflect the content of your email. Avoid vague or misleading subject lines that may disappoint your readers and damage your credibility.

  3. Use action-oriented language: Strong verbs and action-oriented language can make your subject lines more engaging and exciting. Consider using words like "discover," "learn," or "get" to encourage your readers to take action.

  4. Personalize your subject lines: Personalization can help your emails feel more tailored to your reader's interests and needs. Consider using the recipient's name or other relevant details to make your subject line more attention-grabbing.

  5. Ask a question: A well-crafted question can pique your reader's curiosity and encourage them to open your email to find out the answer.

  6. Create a sense of urgency: Limited-time offers, exclusive deals, or time-sensitive information can create a sense of urgency that motivates your readers to take action.

  7. Test and optimize your subject lines: Try out different subject lines and analyze their performance to see what works best for your audience. Over time, you can refine your approach and improve the effectiveness of your subject lines.

By following these tips, you can craft attention-grabbing subject lines that compel your readers to open your emails and engage with your content.

How to use personalization in subject lines

Personalization is a powerful tool that can help you connect with your audience and make your emails feel more relevant and valuable. Here's how to use personalization in your subject lines:

  1. Use the recipient's name: Addressing your reader by name can create a sense of familiarity and make your email feel more personal. Many email marketing platforms allow you to insert the recipient's name into the subject line automatically.

  2. Segment your email list: By segmenting your email list based on factors like location, interests, or behavior, you can tailor your subject lines to be more relevant to each group. For example, if you're promoting a sale on winter coats, you might create separate subject lines for subscribers in colder climates vs. warmer ones.

  3. Use dynamic content: Dynamic content allows you to create multiple versions of an email that are personalized based on specific data points. For example, you might show different products or images in your email based on the recipient's past purchases or browsing history.

  4. Triggered messages: Triggered messages are automated emails that are sent based on specific actions or behaviors, such as abandoning a shopping cart or signing up for a free trial. By using personalized subject lines that reference the recipient's behavior, you can increase the chances of your triggered messages being opened and engaged with.

When using personalization in subject lines, it's important to be careful not to overdo it or use personal information in a way that feels creepy or invasive. By finding the right balance and using personalization in a thoughtful and relevant way, you can create subject lines that make your readers feel seen, valued, and interested in what you have to say.

The power of numbers and statistics in subject lines

Numbers and statistics can be incredibly powerful in subject lines, as they offer a concrete and specific promise to your readers. Here's how to leverage the power of numbers in your subject lines:

  1. Use specific numbers: Specific numbers are more attention-grabbing than vague ones. For example, "5 tips for improving your writing" is more compelling than "a few tips for improving your writing."

  2. Highlight a benefit: Numbers can be used to highlight the benefit that your reader will gain by opening your email. For example, "10% off your next purchase" promises a clear benefit to the reader.

  3. Create a sense of urgency: Numbers can also be used to create a sense of urgency or scarcity. For example, "only 3 spots left" or "limited-time offer: 24 hours only" can motivate your readers to take action quickly.

  4. Use statistics to add credibility: Statistics can be used to add credibility and authority to your subject line. For example, "80% of our customers report higher satisfaction after using our product" highlights a specific benefit that has been quantified.

  5. Be honest and accurate: When using numbers and statistics in subject lines, it's important to be honest and accurate. Misleading or exaggerated claims can damage your credibility and hurt your relationship with your readers.

By using numbers and statistics in your subject lines, you can create a more compelling and specific promise to your readers. Whether you're highlighting a benefit, creating a sense of urgency, or adding credibility, numbers can be a powerful tool in your email marketing arsenal.

Leveraging curiosity and intrigue to increase open rates

Curiosity and intrigue are powerful motivators that can entice readers to open your emails. By leveraging these emotions, you can increase your open rates and engage your audience more effectively. Here's how to use curiosity and intrigue in your subject lines:

  1. Use cliffhangers: Just like in TV shows or movies, cliffhangers can be a powerful way to pique your readers' curiosity and encourage them to open your email to find out what happens next. For example, "The one thing you're doing wrong that's costing you money."

  2. Tease exclusive content: Everyone loves to feel like they're getting access to something special or exclusive. By teasing exclusive content in your subject lines, you can create a sense of intrigue and motivate your readers to open your email. For example, "Get access to our secret recipe for the best brownies you've ever tasted."

  3. Ask a thought-provoking question: Questions can be a great way to get your readers thinking and spark their curiosity. For example, "Did you know that your morning routine might be sabotaging your productivity?" A well-crafted question can create a sense of intrigue and encourage your readers to open your email to find out the answer.

  4. Use mystery or intrigue: Mystery can be a powerful tool in subject lines, especially when used in combination with other techniques like curiosity and exclusivity. For example, "Uncover the hidden secrets of the world's most successful entrepreneurs."

  5. Be relevant and specific: While curiosity and intrigue are important, it's also important to ensure that your subject line accurately reflects the content of your email. Avoid using misleading or clickbaity subject lines that may disappoint your readers and damage your credibility.

By leveraging curiosity and intrigue in your subject lines, you can increase your open rates and engage your readers more effectively. Whether you're using cliffhangers, teasing exclusive content, asking thought-provoking questions, or creating a sense of mystery, there are many ways to use curiosity and intrigue to your advantage in your email marketing efforts.

Avoiding common mistakes in subject line writing

When it comes to writing subject lines for your emails, there are some common mistakes that can hurt your open rates and engagement levels. Here are some of the most common mistakes to avoid:

  1. Being too vague: Vague subject lines can fail to grab your reader's attention and may even come across as spammy. Instead, be specific and clear about the content of your email and the benefits that your readers will gain by opening it.

  2. Being too long: Long subject lines can get cut off in email inboxes and may fail to convey the main point of your email. Keep your subject lines short and to the point, ideally under 50 characters.

  3. Using all caps: Using all caps in your subject lines can be perceived as shouting and may come across as unprofessional. Stick to proper capitalization and avoid using all caps or excessive punctuation.

  4. Using spammy words: Using spammy words like "free", "buy now", or "limited time offer" can trigger spam filters and hurt your deliverability. Instead, focus on using words that convey value and benefit to your readers.

  5. Being misleading: Using misleading subject lines can damage your credibility and hurt your relationship with your readers. Be honest and accurate in your subject lines and avoid clickbait or exaggerated claims.

  6. Ignoring personalization: Personalization can increase open rates and engagement levels by making your emails more relevant and tailored to your readers' interests. Use your reader's name, location, or other relevant information to make your subject lines more personalized.

By avoiding these common mistakes, you can write subject lines that are clear, concise, and compelling, and that effectively communicate the benefits of opening your email. This can lead to higher open rates, engagement levels, and ultimately, better results for your email marketing efforts.

How to test and optimize your subject lines for better results

Testing and optimizing your subject lines is a crucial part of improving your email marketing campaigns. Here's how to test and optimize your subject lines for better results:

  1. Start with a baseline: Before you start testing, establish a baseline for your open rates and engagement levels. This will give you a benchmark to compare your results against and help you identify which subject lines are most effective.

  2. Test one variable at a time: When testing your subject lines, it's important to only test one variable at a time. This could be the length of your subject line, the tone, or the use of personalization. Testing one variable at a time will help you isolate the impact of each variable and identify what works best.

  3. Use A/B testing: A/B testing involves sending two versions of your email to a subset of your audience, each with a different subject line. You can then compare the results to see which subject line performed better and use that one for the rest of your audience.

  4. Analyze your results: Once you've tested your subject lines, it's important to analyze your results and identify what worked and what didn't. Look for trends in your data and try to identify patterns in your successful subject lines.

  5. Optimize your subject lines: Based on your results, optimize your subject lines to improve your open rates and engagement levels. This could involve incorporating successful elements from your tests, testing new variables, or refining your messaging.

By testing and optimizing your subject lines, you can improve the effectiveness of your email marketing campaigns and get better results. Remember to start with a baseline, test one variable at a time, use A/B testing, analyze your results, and optimize your subject lines based on your findings. With some time and effort, you can craft subject lines that grab your reader's attention and encourage them to engage with your content.

Strategies for segmenting your email list to improve subject line relevance

Segmenting your email list can be a powerful way to improve the relevance of your subject lines and increase your open rates. Here are some strategies for segmenting your email list:

  1. Demographic segmentation: Demographic segmentation involves grouping your audience based on demographic criteria such as age, gender, or location. This can help you create subject lines that are more relevant and tailored to each group.

  2. Behavioral segmentation: Behavioral segmentation involves grouping your audience based on their past behavior such as past purchases, email engagement, or website activity. This can help you create subject lines that are more targeted and personalized.

  3. Interest-based segmentation: Interest-based segmentation involves grouping your audience based on their interests and preferences. This can help you create subject lines that speak to your reader's specific interests and needs.

  4. VIP segmentation: VIP segmentation involves creating a special segment for your most valuable customers or subscribers. This can help you create subject lines that are exclusive and tailored to this important group.

  5. Re-engagement segmentation: Re-engagement segmentation involves grouping inactive subscribers and sending them targeted subject lines to encourage them to re-engage with your content. This can help you win back lost subscribers and improve your overall engagement levels.

By segmenting your email list, you can create subject lines that are more relevant and personalized to each group, which can lead to higher open rates and engagement levels. Consider using demographic, behavioral, interest-based, VIP, and re-engagement segmentation to improve the effectiveness of your email marketing campaigns.

Using humor and creativity in subject lines (with caution)

Using humor and creativity in your subject lines can be a great way to grab your reader's attention and make your emails stand out. However, it's important to use humor and creativity with caution.

Here are a few things to keep in mind when using humor and creativity in your subject lines:

  1. Know your audience: Before using humor or being creative in your subject lines, it's important to understand your audience and what will resonate with them. Make sure that your humor is appropriate and not offensive to anyone on your list.

  2. Be careful with puns: Puns can be a great way to add some humor to your subject lines, but they can also be overused and fall flat. Make sure your puns are clever and not too cheesy.

  3. Don't sacrifice clarity: While it's important to be creative, it's even more important that your subject lines are clear and easy to understand. Don't sacrifice clarity in the pursuit of creativity.

  4. Use creativity to enhance your message: Creativity can be a great way to enhance your message and make your subject lines more memorable. Use it to reinforce your main point, not distract from it.

  5. Test your subject lines: As with any aspect of your email marketing campaigns, it's important to test your subject lines to see what works and what doesn't. Test different types of subject lines and see which ones generate the best results.

By using humor and creativity in your subject lines, you can make your emails more engaging and memorable. Just make sure to use it with caution and keep your audience in mind. And remember, always test your subject lines to see what resonates with your subscribers and what generates the best results.

Crafting subject lines that match your brand voice and style

Crafting subject lines that match your brand voice and style is an important aspect of email marketing. Your subject lines should be consistent with your brand's overall messaging and tone.

Here are some tips for crafting subject lines that match your brand voice and style:

  1. Define your brand voice: Your brand voice is the tone, style, and personality of your brand. Before crafting your subject lines, it's important to define your brand voice and ensure that it's consistent across all of your communications.

  2. Use language that matches your brand voice: Once you've defined your brand voice, make sure to use language in your subject lines that matches it. For example, if your brand is known for being friendly and approachable, your subject lines should reflect that tone.

  3. Stay true to your brand's style: Your brand's style should be reflected in your subject lines as well. For example, if your brand is known for using bold, colorful graphics in its marketing materials, you might want to incorporate similar elements in your subject lines.

  4. Be consistent: Consistency is key when it comes to building a strong brand. Make sure your subject lines are consistent with your overall branding and messaging across all of your marketing materials.

  5. Test your subject lines: As with any aspect of your email marketing campaigns, it's important to test your subject lines to see what works and what doesn't. Test different subject lines that reflect your brand voice and style to see which ones generate the best results.

By crafting subject lines that match your brand voice and style, you can build a stronger, more consistent brand image and increase engagement with your email subscribers.

Wrapping up

In the world of email marketing, crafting compelling subject lines can make all the difference in whether your emails are opened and read or sent straight to the trash. In this article, we've covered a range of tips and strategies to help you write subject lines that will capture your audience's attention, increase open rates, and drive engagement.

We started by discussing the importance of subject lines and how they can impact your email marketing success. From there, we covered several specific tips for crafting attention-grabbing subject lines, such as personalization, using numbers and statistics, leveraging curiosity and intrigue, and using humor and creativity with caution.

We also covered common mistakes to avoid when writing subject lines, as well as how to test and optimize your subject lines for better results. Finally, we discussed strategies for segmenting your email list to improve subject line relevance and how to craft subject lines that match your brand voice and style.

By following these tips and strategies, you can write subject lines that capture your audience's attention, drive engagement, and ultimately help you achieve your email marketing goals.

Want to personalize your emails and landing pages? Try Markettailor for free.


Related posts

The Role of UTM Tagging in Influencer Marketing

Influencer marketing has been taking the marketing world by storm, and for good reason. With the rise of social media, people are now more likely to trust the opinions and recommendations of their favorite influencers over traditional advertisements. But how can brands effectively measure the...

Read more

Improving Email Engagement with UTM Tagging

Email marketing is a crucial part of digital marketing, but getting your target audience to engage with your emails can be a challenge. With a cluttered inbox and an endless stream of emails, it can be hard to stand out and get your message heard. That's where UTM (Urchin Tracking Module) tagging...

Read more